The housing supply shortage in Canada has been a major driver of high home prices and escalating rents, particularly in cities like Toronto, Vancouver, and Montreal. The gap between demand and the available housing stock is a key issue that governments and developers are struggling to address.
Now that the ongoing threats of Tariffs are coming to fruition, another hurdle appears with the ongoing struggle, along with factors like immigration, low vacancy rates, and shifting demographics. This shortage is especially pronounced in the affordable housing segment, where low-income and first-time buyers face significant barriers.
Table of Contents
New Construction Challenges
The shortage of supply is being compounded by several factors that make new construction difficult and costly.
Labor Shortages
The construction industry has faced significant labor shortages in recent years, particularly in skilled trades, which slows down the pace of new housing projects.
Material Costs and Supply Chain Issues
Tariffs and other trade disruptions have led to higher costs for key construction materials like lumber, steel, and drywall. Additionally, supply chain delays, which began during the pandemic, are still affecting the timely delivery of materials to construction sites.
Zoning and Regulation
In some areas, strict zoning laws and lengthy approval processes are limiting the ability to quickly build new housing, especially in high-demand urban areas. There’s also local resistance to new development, particularly in the form of NIMBYism (Not In My Backyard), where communities are reluctant to welcome more density or affordable housing projects.
Tariffs & Trade Tensions
Both the U.S. and Canada have recently announced tariffs on construction materials, particularly softwood lumber, which plays a crucial role in housing construction. The U.S. has historically imposed tariffs on Canadian lumber exports, and in turn, Canada has raised tariffs on certain U.S. goods as well. These tariffs could have several consequences:
Potential Negative Effects of Tariffs
Increased Construction Costs
The most immediate impact of tariffs on materials like softwood lumber is a rise in costs for builders. This makes new construction more expensive, which in turn raises the price of new homes and other housing projects. As construction costs go up, developers may scale back projects, especially in the affordable housing sector, which could worsen the supply shortage.
Reduced Housing Supply Growth
With higher material costs, builders may delay or cancel new housing developments, further exacerbating the supply shortage. The housing market may also see fewer new homes built in the near term, especially in regions where demand for new housing is particularly high. This would not only affect homeowners but could also lead to longer wait times for renters and a continued imbalance between supply and demand.
Increased Rent Prices
For developers working on rental properties, the added costs of construction could be passed on to tenants, further driving up rents. With more expensive housing options and fewer affordable ones being built, renters will continue to feel the strain.
Potential Positive Effects of Tariffs
Encouragement of Domestic Production
Tariffs may incentivize domestic production of building materials like lumber, which could help reduce dependency on international supply chains. Canada could increase its own production of softwood lumber to meet demand, creating new opportunities for domestic manufacturers and potentially reducing long-term price volatility in construction materials.
Increased Innovation and Efficiency
With rising costs and fewer materials available at lower prices, builders and developers might be forced to find new methods to reduce construction expenses, such as adopting more efficient building practices, using alternative materials, or embracing modular and prefab construction. This could eventually lead to lower construction costs and a more streamlined housing supply process.
Support for Local Economies
If Canada were to produce more building materials domestically in response to the tariffs, it could lead to job creation in local manufacturing sectors, potentially boosting the economy in regions where these materials are produced. Additionally, construction and manufacturing are both key sectors that contribute to regional growth and development.
Strengthened Trade Negotiations
The tariffs could encourage both governments to negotiate better trade terms related to construction materials, which might lead to lower long-term costs for builders and a more stable supply of necessary materials.
Long-Term Outlook
The ultimate effect of these tariffs will depend on how long they remain in place, how quickly the Canadian and U.S. construction industries can adapt, and whether alternative trade agreements or policy measures are put in place to reduce the negative impacts. In the short term, the supply shortage could worsen, leading to higher home prices and rents, but in the long term, increased domestic production and efficiency improvements could help stabilize the market and improve housing affordability.
